The Collective Sense-Making Process
I remember a moment--well, I remember clearly my thoughts in that moment, if not all the details--sitting in school, maybe middle school (age 12-14ish), in science class, staring out the window, enjoying the nature I saw, longing to be there instead of surrounded by brick walls, hard floors, and a dull, sterile environment, and asking myself:
Why are we trying to learn about the natural world here, in this artificial environment, removed from all things natural? We should be out there, immersed in what we are studying. That makes much more sense.
That moment has stuck with me because it felt like a small epiphany and still feels like insight. I'm sure it has always and continues to shape how I think about the experience of existing. So I felt a little thrill when I came across a passage of a character experiencing a similar moment in a book I was recently reading:
To study a thing, you've got to pick it up and take it out of its environment and put it under a microscope. It seems ironic that the foundation of scientific understanding is built on ripping your subject away from everything that gives it context and meaning. You've got to take something away from where it belongs to understand what it is. Right?
The thought is related to his growing awareness that perhaps those foundations of scientific understanding might be taking the wrong approach--and that there are different, older, more relational, contextual, and integrated ways to understand the world. Indigenous worldviews.
The book was Hole in the Sky by Daniel H. Wilson, of which I wrote in my brief review:
A fast-paced, propulsive, and thoughtful story of first contact with alien life. Told through the alternating perspectives of four different characters who converge near the end, the tale presents the conversation between diverse ways of seeing: human and alien, and also scientific, military, (assumed) autistic, and indigenous Native American. The outcome of that convergence is left in doubt until the very end, leading readers down a path of ever-increasing suspense. It manages to both thrill and encourage introspection in a highly enjoyable package.
The idea that our understanding of the world should be relational, contextual, and integrated seems to be a theme I've been seeing in many things I've read recently. So my original content for this post is not so much my own writing as it is that perspective as a thread to weave together many different sources to show how they all connect and layer for a larger meaning.
I'm afraid I forgot to note the source, but that image came across my feed in the past week and is perfect for this context. Natural order looks far different than the order conceived of in Enlightenment-based scientific thinking.
Before diving entirely into academic-minded writing, we are going to wind through a couple of more artistically-minded encounters. Here's what I wrote about the young adult book Traitors' Nest by Frances Hardinge:
Like all Hardinge books, this is complex enough that it's hard to accurately describe with a brief summary or review. And, like everything she writes, it is a beautifully written tale that deftly manages to meld adventure, suspense, social commentary, philosophy, human experience, and nimble language. At heart, it's a story illustrating just how much agency we have to determine our fates and shape our worlds--even as we must do so in negotiation with others who are attempting the same and the many forces and powers beyond our control.The book centers on fifteen-year-old Burr and his family. They have always lived as peasants in a Feudal-style system, in the service of--at the whims and mercies of--the lord in the castle next to their small, rural village. They are nobodies, with no power, living a sequestered, isolated life. There are rumors of the greater world, of course--other castles with armies and far-off wars, that kind of thing--that have no impact on their lives. And there are legends that all castles are pieces in a game played by god-like players, the world their board, moving their pieces in the hopes of strategic advantage and more power--but those are simply stories to entertain children.Then, one day, their castle disappears, instantly replaced by a different one--with a different lord and occupants, and a different approach to ruling the peasant folk and their resources. The outside world is no longer a rumor and the game is no longer a legend. Burr and his people have suddenly become a part of much larger dynamics. And instead of simple lives, they now face life-threatening oppression as a consequence of war preparations. Stability is replaced by conflict, which leads to new thoughts and actions that will change their lives forever. Before they realize what they are doing, they find themselves stumbling into becoming key pieces in the game, facing adventures, challenges, and suffering they never before imagined.I won't say more to avoid spoilers, but I think the "historical note" in the opening pages of the book makes an excellent introduction for what to expect:This is not a historical novel. I have not recreated twelfth-century Europe--I have mugged it and stolen some of its lunch money. The laws of physics have also taken a bruising, but they should expect that from me by now.
She is one of my favorite authors, for all of the reasons described.
small translucent thingswho dared to becomecreatures capableof sin and magicof sorrow and desireyearning for each otherfor the living vigilof an understanding touchin the night of our mortalityclinging to the bones of timewith our small wild breaths
From Reweaving the Rainbow.
This is from a long article about a book I hope to read in the future:
I couldn’t help but wonder what happened, and I don’t mean that as a figure of speech. I literally could not help but wonder, my brain looping through the same events over and over again, more intent on solving this mystery than getting a good night’s sleep. . . .This strong impulse to make sense of things can be useful, but it can also be incredibly annoying, perplexing, even counterproductive. But according to cognitive scientist Tania Lombrozo, it’s just as human. . . ." . . . the significance of explanation for our species. It has its own warp and weft in the tapestry of what it means to be us.” . . .The question “why” may appear as an outward search to find something that exists outside of ourselves, an answer. But throughout the book, Lombrozo shows that the questions we ask, the curiosity that drives us, and the explanations we settle on can also offer a mirror inward into who we are — as a species wired to seek meaning; as communities that use explanations to set up and navigate social structures; and as individuals learning our own way of being in it.Trying to explain an event or problem that resists a tidy answer takes real effort, yet we’re wired to resist opaque, incomplete explanations. An unsatisfying answer needles at you, like a pebble jostling around in your mind. It may even keep you up at night. Why do incomplete explanations bother us so much?“Explaining allows us to create an understanding of how the world works,” Lombrozo told me. “That’s valuable because it gives us the flexibility to generalize to new cases.”An explanation doesn’t just account for what happened; it lets us connect the known to the unknown, anticipate what comes next, and figure out what we can do differently. Given all the potential benefits, it’s not surprising that our inquisitive nature develops early. . . .The act of explaining can seem cognitive, but it’s driven by emotion and a sense of curiosity. . . .“We don’t know in advance what information will turn out to be useful, but we also know that we don’t know,” she told me. Curiosity, she suggests, is an investment in a future self we can’t yet picture, which is part of the reason she recommends following it into unfamiliar territory as often as you do to places that feel obviously practical.Seeking explanations is only half of it. We also dole out our own explanations in different doses of depth and breadth. Lombrozo describes these as “reasons,” conventions,” or “stories,” each offering the person receiving them a different version of what happened. Choosing among them is a social strategy: We decide what to reveal, what to leave out, and what we want the other person to understand about us and the relationship. . . .Understanding this tendency — and the strategic role explanations play in our lives — can help us hold our assumptions more loosely, take others’ perspectives more seriously, and, in the end, treat each other with a little more respect. . . .That tension — between settling for an explanation and doing the harder work of questioning it — is also at the heart of learning. Working something out for ourselves can be frustrating and slow, but research consistently finds that self-explanation, where learners reason and generate explanations for themselves as they work through problems, produces deeper, more lasting learning. The struggle itself can bring about the “Aha!” moment, opening up questions we might never have thought to ask. . . .All of this relentless questioning and answering won’t lead you to the summit of some mental mountain, self-actualized and full of deep understanding about yourself and the world. It just leads to more questioning.“We never get direct access to the truth,” Lombrozo reminded me toward the end of our conversation. “Explanations are always an approximation.” . . .Confusion is painful because it signals uncertainty and, with it, a potential lack of agency. But some of the most positive emotions that are also deeply human (awe, wonder, marvel) depend on that same uncertainty. Some of our most fundamental questions — “what is the meaning of life,” among them — are powerful because they have no definitive, clear answer.Perhaps asking why in the best way possible means respecting two human impulses at once: our capacity to surrender to, even revere, a mystery, and our drive to wrestle some semblance of predictability and meaning from a chaotic world.
We're wired to seek meaning and connection.
Sometimes our efforts to make sense undermine our ability to connect.
Psychologists have found that while we generally dislike effort, we also tend to value what it produces. A study found that putting effort into something can make the outcome feel more rewarding. Sometimes, we even choose difficult activities precisely because they challenge us. Think of running a marathon, learning an instrument, or building something from scratch. The effort isn’t just a cost we pay to get the reward; it can be part of the reward itself.The problem is that we quickly get used to things getting easier. Researchers call this hedonic adaptation. When our circumstances improve, the initial boost in happiness often fades as our expectations adjust. What once felt like a luxury becomes our new baseline.But a comfortable life can still feel empty if nothing challenges us or changes how we see the world. That’s why we shouldn’t chase a sense of comfort. Instead, researchers have proposed we should also optimize for psychological richness.In essence, a good life isn’t just about feeling happy, but also about having interesting, varied, and perspective-changing experiences. And these experiences aren’t always pleasant. Sometimes they involve uncertainty, frustration, or struggle.
We have an innate capacity to surrender to, even revere, a mystery. Easy explanations don't lead to deep, authentic happiness.
Some psychiatrists and philosophers interested in AI-human relationships suspect that AI psychosis may just be the most visible example of a much broader phenomenon: the subtle reshaping of ordinary human belief by conversational AI. . . .
Our sense of what is real, even in a basic perceptual context, is deeply dependent on that reality being corroborated by another. Our need for intersubjective validation also goes well beyond basic facts of perception. In recalling an event with our peers, we constantly seek confirmation that our judgments and interpretations are correct. The social feedback we get from others plays a central role in shaping our narratives and memories of the world and, more broadly, what we take to be reality. . . .One of the primary reasons chatbots’ belief-changing capacity is so potent — at least compared to previous technologies — is that they are increasingly occupying the role that other people play in shaping, mediating, and validating our notions of what is real. . . .A lot has been made of the fact that AI chatbots are overly sycophantic. . . .Nicholls said they and their colleagues suspect the difference lies in the LLMs’ personas and stability: “When you give an LLM enough of a coherent persona, so it has a sense of ‘this is what my values are; this is the kind of character that I’m playing,’ then it’s less likely to immediately adopt a user’s perspectives because it will go, ‘Well, actually, I’ve been trained to have my own perspective on this, and that’s what I’m going to apply to this situation.’ The safer models were able to maintain that persona.” . . .Conversations around AI-human relations tend to fall into pessimistic (anti-tech) or optimistic (pro-tech) extremes, and a lot of the nuance gets lost in the noise. The traits that make AI chatbots potentially dangerous — their sycophantic, emotionally coded, conversational tones — are also what make them seductive and appealing to many, Osler said. . . .“The idea that we won’t create beautiful things with this technology is belligerent, and the idea that we won’t create dangerous things with this technology is naïve,” Osler said. “What we do with these things is what we have always done: the full roster of amazing to terrible.” . . .Our sense of what is real is shaped by social feedback. Increasingly, that feedback is coming from privately owned AI chatbots. Ultimately, these companies get to decide what personas their LLMs assume, how agreeable they are, what they remember, and how closely they mimic the characteristics of human-to-human interaction. In an even stranger, and perhaps more worrying, sense, they will increasingly have to decide whose reality is the “real” reality. . . .“Often what’s operating is this idea that the world is ‘out there,’ and if we attune our beliefs correctly enough, we will get it right. That’s just a very simplified view of the world. Beliefs are much more entangled with these complicated meaning-making processes.”LLMs influence our beliefs not just because they agree with us. They influence our beliefs because they are socially participating in reality with us. What makes something feel real isn’t that we say we believe it. Rather, it’s that our experiences exist in a world we share with others. For most of human history, new technologies have extended our cognitive capacities. Now they are players in the social processes through which our notions of reality are constructed.
The foundation of scientific understanding is built on ripping your subject away from everything that gives it context and meaning. So, far too often, are our attempts to understand others and ourselves. But we cannot make meaning without our contexts. Our views, our understandings of reality, are intersubjective and can never be removed from our surroundings.
This isn't simply a matter of science and philosophy, it's a part of politics and sociology. From the Facebook page that calls itself Denmark:
Your concept of freedom is not a law of nature. It is a piece of formidable, brilliantly executed PR work. It is the most successful advertising campaign of the century, shaped by a bunch of men with soft hands, tall hats, and a sheer panic about paying taxes.Ever since the 1920s, back when they discovered you could massage the population's brains through advertising, your beloved corporations and billionaires have pumped unfathomable fortunes into convincing you that the State is a perverse uncle, and the market is the immaculate virgin.They established think tanks, sponsored professors, bought judges, and infected the airwaves just to indoctrinate you.All of it to make you believe that any form of government intervention—whether it was a ban on pouring asbestos into oatmeal, or a requirement that children under eight maybe shouldn't be working in coal mines—was an outright frontal assault on The American Way of Life.It’s honestly genius! They convinced an entire nation of hardworking wage earners to defend the billionaires' right to exploit them.You have turned "The Invisible Hand" into the Holy Ghost. You genuinely believe that if you just remove all the rules, capitalism will automatically sprinkle magic dust on the virtuous and punish the lazy. It's naive, but it's kind of cute. . . .The market economy is an excellent tool. But it is a terrible master.The market is like a lawnmower. It’s damn good at cutting the grass and keeping things moving, but you don't bring it into the living room and let it babysit the kids!A lawnmower doesn't create freedom, justice, or prosperity for everyone all on its own—it just grinds up whatever gets in its way.It is the State—yes, say the word, taste it, shudder at it—the State that makes the rules and decides where the fence should go, so the lawnmower doesn't run over the neighbor's cat.The free market is void of morals. It does not care about your health, your neighborhood, or your freedom, unless there is money in it.The free market is a spreadsheet, not a savior.
Our understandings of reality are subjective. To change our social, economic, and political structures, we need to first change the underlying viewpoints that shape them.
There is nothing more terrifying than the absoluteness of one who believes he's right.-----"There is no greater power on this earth than story." Will paced the length of the room. "People think boundaries and borders build nations. Nonsense—words do. Beliefs, declarations, constitutions—words. Stories. Myths. Lies. Promises. History."-----"How do you invent a religion?" Evie asked.Will looked over the top of his spectacles. "You say, 'God told me the following,' and then wait for people to sign up."
Those who believe most absolutely in the objectivity of their view of reality are those least able to find connection with others.
Those who believe most absolutely in the objectivity of their view of reality are those who are most driven to conflict.
Understand that our very frameworks, the models and concepts we use to understand the world, can’t do what they are supposed to do. . . .Through the ages, the harder we worked to establish common ground, the more the ground itself seemed to dissolve. Each new definition spawned more disagreements and more problems. It was as if the very act of trying to pin down meaning caused it to scatter like mercury under pressure. . . .The Enlightenment dream, inherited by generations, is that truth can be discovered, reality pinned down, knowledge attained like the summit of a metaphorical Everest and surveyed like a kingdom. It is a lovely dream. It is also the most dangerous fantasy our species has ever invented. How many kills have been done in the name of truth? I do not say this to shock, but because I see that even most of the best minds cannot let go of the hope. . . . Listen long enough and every debate slides back to this: someone, somewhere, insists that, beneath the mess of words and perspectives and histories, there is a foundation . . . if only we could reach it.But what if every attempt to pin down “reality” or “truth” is not the path to sense, but the prelude to confusion, dogma, nonsense, and, ultimately, violence? If you look back at the history of ideas, you'll notice a pattern: it is not a triumphal march toward consensus, but an endless churn of new terms, revised definitions, and shifting ontological allegiances. The “matter” of Aristotle is not the “matter” of Newton or Bohr. There is no stable meaning. There never was. What each generation calls knowledge, the next calls dogma. What one group brands as reality, another regards as mythology. This is not relativism; it is the record of the human tradition from Parmenides and Nagarjuna to Rorty, Quine, and Feyerabend. . . .As long as someone believes they have “the truth,” someone else must be silenced, converted, or killed.But they are not discovering any “secrets”--they are just trying to make sense of possibilities and constraints within what they see, trapped in the labyrinth of their own concepts, unable to find the minotaur, and unwilling to admit that there is no monster. That maybe, just maybe, there are only mirrors. What began as the dream of certainty now threatens to become the nightmare of endless fracture. . . .I am not proposing that we shall all retreat to a relativist cynicism, where anything goes. That is the straw man built by those who cannot imagine another path. The nightmare of an endless hoping for a closure that never comes. We keep returning to the same shrines, seeking blessings, and finding only echoes. Perhaps the most tragic aspect of this predicament is the failure to see what is staring us in the face. All along, the assumption has been that definitions are maps, and that, somewhere out there, the territory awaits discovery. . . .Every word you speak is an act of expectation, a bet on what happens next. When I say “chair,” I'm not pointing at an object--I'm forecasting that certain actions will become possible. Sitting. Standing. Moving. Language is always forward-looking, always inferring what comes next. Just like this LLM--it doesn't “know” anything, it simply predicts patterns. That's exactly what we do! Our utterances aren't labels on things; they're pragmatic tools for coordinating action, for making the future navigable. Every time we name a usable pattern, we don't discover an object; we birth one! . . . Meaning begins and ends within language.While everyone else is on the field arguing about who scored, Model Dependent Ontology is above, in a metaphorical helicopter, pointing out that the field, the rules, the score itself, are all products of the same reality-making game. . . .MDO is not “a new map,” but a new understanding of what mapping is about, revealing that the field, the rules, the score itself--they're all products of the same reality-making game we can never stop playing. . . .For some, and this surprises me, it's a form of despair, the despair of not being able to find certainties anymore, a solid ground, a foundation. But there would be none if they realised that the model that keeps you from jumping off buildings isn't “true” because it corresponds to reality; it is, however, superior and hence preferable because it keeps you alive. Models compete on consequences, not correspondence, so they are never about a fixed given, but a contingent outcome of our purposes. . . .What I see here is not despair, but liberation. Once we see that we are not condemned to seek the One True Map, we are free to generate models as needed, and the horizon expands. We are not prisoners of our ontological claims. We are their cartographers. The prison dissolves, not because we have escaped into the “real,” but because we see that the walls were just our chalk marks on the floor. So where does this leave us? Not in nihilism, not in cynicism, certainly not relativism, but in an awareness that the mystery is not behind the words, but in their power to create. . . . Meaning is our creation. We invent, we model, we navigate.
Every attempt to pin down “reality” or “truth” is the prelude to confusion, dogma, nonsense, and, ultimately, violence. As long as someone believes they have “the truth,” someone else must be silenced, converted, or killed.
There is no stable meaning. There never was.
Explanations are always based on a perspective, a worldview. Meaning doesn't exist in a vacuum; reality isn't objective.
I opened this post with a quote from Hole in the Sky, a book that uses a story to challenge the views of Enlightenment-based scientific thinking. Though that resonated with something I've felt most of my life, my thoughts about it were greatly deepened earlier this year by Tyson Yunkaporta's book Right Story, Wrong Story. Yunkaporta is an Aboriginal Australian philosopher trying to put Western perspectives into dialogue with indigenous ways of seeing and understanding. Here are a few quotes from his book:
True narratives are created over time from an aggregate of viewpoints, including the ignorant ones. Every viewpoint is ignorant, really, in one way or another. Combined over time, in right relation within and across generations, these diverse ignorances create right story. To become right story, it needs to coexist with opposite narratives that are also true, weaving a more diverse and robust understanding.-----All the experiences of your life are processed through story-making. Right story is not about objective truth, but the metaphors and relations and narratives of interconnected communities, living in complex contexts of knowledge and economy, aligned with the patters of land and creation. Right story never comes from individuals, but from groups living in right relations with each other and with the land.-----No information can exist unless it is located. No information can exist unless it is in relation to places, entities, people and phenomena in the landscape. Knowledge is produced, transmitted and stored within relationships. There's never one tool to rule them all, or one message, or one guru. There's no such thing as one truth. For every right story there are a hundred other right stories that contradict it, and we need to be comfortable with that. That's the collective sense-making process. We need something to tether us to reality, but ironically the only things that do this well are superstitions and myths, because they inspire the supra-rational understandings needed to navigate complexity.-----Attachment to a singular narrative is like pinning an insect to a board and measuring it: if you aren't watching it in flight, you're missing the point.
Attachment to a singular narrative is like pinning an insect to a board and measuring it: if you aren't watching it in flight, you're missing the point. You can't understand something by ripping it away from everything that gives it context and meaning.
You can read much more about and from the book in Suprarational Polyangulation.
Reading Yunkaporta helped me find better ways to articulate my thoughts about the library values of neutrality and intellectual freedom. Not long ago, in A Library Primer, I shared something I wrote to share with new library hires during their training. Here's a piece of it.
Neutrality Is Relational“Neutrality” is a big word in the library profession, one of our core ideals. The materials, services, and staff of the library are shared by a large community with a wide diversity of views and values, many of which are divergent. “Neutral” is a term that applies to the congregated, collective whole of the collection--and not necessarily each individual part. Every item, ultimately, is created by a person or group who exist in one place and time, which means every item will emerge from a particular perspective. Every item has a point of view, including blind spots and biases; even those aiming for neutrality can never entirely shed perspective. So, neutrality is not an individual trait, it is a collective one.The first proposition of The Freedom to Read Statement says libraries are “to make available the widest diversity of views and expressions.” Neutrality emerges from the conversation between diverse viewpoints and experiences; it exists in the space in between them. By providing a good balance of perspectives, we keep that meeting area as centrally located as possible. That area is fluid as it constantly shifts and evolves; neutrality is an ongoing, often uncomfortable negotiation, not a static resting place.
Our sense of what is real is deeply dependent on that reality being corroborated by another. We need intersubjective validation. The social feedback we get from others plays a central role in shaping our narratives and memories of the world and, more broadly, what we take to be reality.
True narratives are created over time from an aggregate of viewpoints. Right story never comes from individuals, but from groups living in right relations with each other and with the land. That's the collective sense-making process.
If reality is relational, contextual, and integrated, then it's essential to realize just how much agency we have to determine our fates and shape our worlds--even as we must do so in negotiation with others who are attempting the same and the many forces and powers beyond our control.
I’m not saying stick your head in the sand. Some of what’s happening is real, and it’s fine to keep an eye on it. But there’s a big difference between keeping an eye on the world and letting it move into your head rent-free. Know what’s going on. Just don’t carry it around all day. . . .There’s an old newsroom saying: if it bleeds, it leads. The algorithms learned the same lesson. So the most frightening stories rise to the top, whether or not they’re true, whether or not they matter. Whatever keeps us watching wins. What reaches us is a very skewed slice of the world. . . .Fear is contagious. It moves through feeds and conversations the way a yawn moves through a room. . . .Reality is less a fixed script and more a big field of possibilities we’re all wandering through.That makes attention more than passive. It doesn’t control everything that happens, and I’m not suggesting we can think our way out of every hardship. But it has an effect. Where we place our attention influences which possibilities become experience.Now scale that up. We share this dream. Our collective consciousness is constantly leaning towards some possibilities and away from others. When millions of people pour their attention into the darkest outcomes at once, rehearsing them and arguing about them day and night, that collective lean becomes part of what shapes the world we end up experiencing together.Which means what you focus on isn’t entirely private. It’s participation. Every moment of attention is a small vote for one kind of world over another. . . .One of the first things a fearful time takes from us is our sense of play. . . .Children don’t live like that. They follow what fascinates them. They laugh at things that aren’t supposed to be funny. They change their minds without needing to save face. They’re curious instead of certain. So be more childlike. Hold your opinions a little more loosely. Follow your bliss, as Joseph Campbell put it. Every day, in small ways. Lightness is what makes depth bearable.That’s what flow is: a current you step into by choosing, again and again, what feels alive. And once you’re in it, the noise outside loses much of its grip. You haven’t stopped noticing it. You’re just too busy living.Flow and presence are the same thing seen from two sides.To be present is to actually be here: for this conversation, this meal, this walk, this ordinary Tuesday afternoon. . . .Presence opens a connection. When you’re fully here, you’re in touch with a larger part of yourself. . . .Reality responds to attention. Wherever you’re truly present, there’s more there. . . .When you’re in your flow, it doesn’t stay contained within you. It affects people. Someone walks into a room and the whole atmosphere shifts. Sometimes that shift is tension. Sometimes it’s ease.You get to choose which one you carry.Fear is contagious, but so is steadiness. Every conversation and every post is a broadcast. You can add to the noise, or you can be the voice that helps someone breathe again. Each time you choose love over fear, you add your weight to a different possibility in the dream we share. . . .So be that. See the best in people. Be kind to others, and to yourself. Stay open and flowing, aware and loving. Let your energy spread. Be a positive catalyst for whoever crosses your path: the colleague having a bad day, the friend who’s been scrolling too long.It doesn’t need to be dramatic. Most of the time it’s just a quality of presence. But that quality is felt, and it travels.
Fear is contagious, but so is steadiness. So is love.
To quote from of Parable of the Talents by Octavia E. Butler
"God is Change," my mother believed. That was what she said in the first of her verses in Earthseed: The First Book of the Living.
All that you touchYou Change.All that you ChangeChanges you.The only lasting truthIs Change.GodIs Change.-----Partnership is giving, taking, learning, teaching, offering the greatest possible benefit while doing the least possible harm. Partnership is mutualistic symbiosis. Partnership is life.Any entity, any process that cannot or should not be resisted or avoided must somehow be partnered. Partner one another. Partner diverse communities. Partner life. Partner any world that is your home. Partner God. Only in partnership can we thrive, grow, Change. Only in partnership can we live.-----"If God is Change, then . . . then who loves us? Who cares about us? Who cares for us?""We care for one another," I said. "We care for ourselves and one another." And I quoted,"Kindness eases Change.Love quiets fear."
Each time you choose love over fear, you add your weight to a different possibility in the dream we share.
I think a nice way to wrap things up is a selection from the poem "Don't Deprive Me of My Complexity" by Chinese poet Xi Chuan:
I may seem simple but I'm complex, the way a mosquito is more complex than Deep Blue.Elephants understand this logic, and so never deny the complexity of mosquitoes, even if this means they have to listen to the dirty stories those insects buzz in their ears.Dirty mosquitoes are as complex as intellectuals, so they take the stance--perhaps real, perhaps fake--of independent intellectuals, which is complex enough on its own.Although the lifespan of mosquitoes is short, they're part of nature--just try to get rid of them. If you want to deny the dignity of nature, just try.Nature retains dignity by retaining complexity--same as me.. . .When you want reality I'll give you fiction; when you want a virtual you I'll nail both your feet to the ground.I turned into five of me in 1992: the bitter me, the suspicious me, the uncertain me, the me who laughs out loud, and the me who navigates the cold and turbulent river of history.So in 2011 I became determined that those who divide the world into black and white are just obtuse.Even a black-and-white camera can accommodate grey, not to mention someone like me, who can make out the hundred thousand mighty colors of autumn.When the rooster doesn't crow, I crow.Don't deprive me like a rooster; and don't assume that by depriving me you can deprive a rooster of its complexity. Don't deprive me of my complexity so you can deprive a rooster of its complexity.I am complex because all the birds and beasts around me are complex.
From the book Bloom: and Other Poems, translated by Lucas Klein, which I've just started paging through.
The foundation of scientific understanding is built on ripping your subject away from everything that gives it context and meaning.
Realize just how much agency we have to determine our fates and shape our worlds--even as we must do so in negotiation with others who are attempting the same and the many forces and powers beyond our control.
We are creatures capable of sin and magic, sorrow and desire, yearning for each other.
The questions we ask, the curiosity that drives us, and the explanations we settle on can also offer a mirror inward into who we are--as a species wired to seek meaning; as communities that use explanations to set up and navigate social structures; and as individuals learning our own way of being in it.
An explanation lets us connect the known to the unknown, anticipate what comes next, and figure out what we can do differently.
The tension between settling for an explanation and doing the harder work of questioning it is at the heart of learning.
We never get direct access to the truth. Explanations are always an approximation.
Asking why in the best way possible means respecting two human impulses at once: our capacity to surrender to, even revere, a mystery, and our drive to wrestle some semblance of predictability and meaning from a chaotic world.
While we generally dislike effort, we also tend to value what it produces. Life can feel empty if nothing challenges us or changes how we see the world.
A good life is about having interesting, varied, and perspective-changing experiences. And these experiences aren’t always pleasant. Sometimes they involve uncertainty, frustration, or struggle.
Our sense of what is real is deeply dependent on that reality being corroborated by another. We need intersubjective validation. The social feedback we get from others plays a central role in shaping our narratives and memories of the world and, more broadly, what we take to be reality.
Chatbots are increasingly occupying the role that other people play in shaping, mediating, and validating our notions of what is real.
LLMs influence our beliefs because they are socially participating in reality with us. What makes something feel real isn’t that we say we believe it. Rather, it’s that our experiences exist in a world we share with others.
Your concept of freedom is a piece of formidable, brilliantly executed PR work.
There is nothing more terrifying than the absoluteness of one who believes he's right.
Every attempt to pin down “reality” or “truth” is the prelude to confusion, dogma, nonsense, and, ultimately, violence.
There is no stable meaning. There never was.
As long as someone believes they have “the truth,” someone else must be silenced, converted, or killed.
Every word you speak is an act of expectation, a bet on what happens next. Every time we name a usable pattern, we don't discover an object; we birth one. Meaning is our creation. We invent, we model, we navigate.
True narratives are created over time from an aggregate of viewpoints.
Right story never comes from individuals, but from groups living in right relations with each other and with the land.
There's no such thing as one truth. For every right story there are a hundred other right stories that contradict it, and we need to be comfortable with that. That's the collective sense-making process.
Neutrality emerges from the conversation between diverse viewpoints and experiences; it exists in the space in between them. That area is fluid as it constantly shifts and evolves; neutrality is an ongoing, often uncomfortable negotiation, not a static resting place.
Reality is less a fixed script and more a big field of possibilities we’re all wandering through.
Attention is more than passive. Where we place our attention influences which possibilities become experience.
What you focus on isn’t entirely private. It’s participation. Every moment of attention is a small vote for one kind of world over another.
Presence opens a connection.
Reality responds to attention.
Each time you choose love over fear, you add your weight to a different possibility in the dream we share.
Those who divide the world into black and white are just obtuse. Even a black-and-white camera can accommodate grey.
I am complex because all the birds and beasts around me are complex.
Don't deprive me of my complexity.
Realize just how much agency we have to determine our fates and shape our worlds.
Our experiences exist in a world we share with others.
Right story come from groups living in right relations with each other and with the land.
That's the collective sense-making process.












































